An essential topic for everyone in the business world, whether selling products or providing services, is Consumer Rights. To understand the Consumer Protection Code and how to navigate it, it's crucial to know some general principles the law brings, such as: the difference between a defect and a fault in a product or service, the rights of consumers, the obligations of suppliers, and, very importantly, in which situations the supplier is not liable for the defect or fault of the product. But let's start from the beginning...
Consumer Protection Code Unveiled - Who's Who?
Before anything else, it's essential to understand the basic premises upon which the Consumer Protection Code was created and to know who is who in the eyes of the law. The Consumer Protection Code (CPC) establishes clear definitions for the terms "consumer" and "supplier," laying the groundwork for understanding the consumer relationships regulated by this code. Let's detail these definitions to facilitate understanding:
Consumer
According to article 2 of the CPC, a consumer is any natural or legal person who acquires or uses a product or service as the final recipient. This definition encompasses any individual or company that, when purchasing a product or service, does so with the purpose of satisfying a personal, family, business, or professional need, without the intention of integrating the acquired product or used service into a process of production, transformation, or commercialization intended for third parties.
Moreover, the CPC extends protection to the consumer in article 17, including the figure of the "equivalent consumer." This covers people exposed to commercial and contractual practices, even if they are not the direct purchasers of the product or service, such as, for example, victims of accidents caused by defects in products.
Supplier
Article 3 of the CPC defines a supplier as any natural or legal person, public or private, national or foreign, as well as unpersonified entities, that engage in activities of production, assembly, creation, construction, transformation, importation, exportation, distribution, or commercialization of products or provision of services.
This definition is quite broad and includes, therefore, any economic agent that puts products or services into the consumer market, whether by manufacturing, importing, distributing, or selling, regardless of its size or legal nature. The goal is to ensure that the entire production and distribution chain is covered by consumer protection norms.
Importance of These Definitions
Understanding who the consumers and suppliers are from the CPC's perspective is crucial for small business owners, as it allows them to clearly identify the responsibilities and rights in any commercial transaction. This helps ensure that business practices are aligned with legislation, promoting healthy and equitable consumer relationships. Moreover, a clear understanding of these concepts aids in conflict resolution and in the implementation of customer service and after-sales strategies that respect consumer rights, contributing to customer loyalty and satisfaction.
Having made this explanation and now that you know who is who for the CPC, let's talk about the premises; those principles that the code has elected as truths and upon which it stands
Principles of the Consumer Protection Code (CPC)
The Consumer Protection Code (CPC) is a set of norms aimed at protecting consumer rights, in addition to guiding the relationships and responsibilities between consumers and suppliers. For small business owners, understanding the basic principles of the CPC is crucial, as they guide the interpretation and application of the law in various everyday business situations. Let's explore the most relevant principles:
Principle of Vulnerability: The consumer is always considered the weaker party in the consumer relationship. This means not only economic vulnerability but also technical and informational vulnerability. This principle is the foundation of the CPC, recognizing that the consumer needs special protection in commercial transactions.
Principle of Transparency: Requires that all information about products and services be clear, accurate, and easily accessible, allowing the consumer to make well-informed choices. This includes details about characteristics, quality, quantity, composition, price, guarantees, deadlines, health and safety risks, among others.
Principle of Good Faith: Both consumers and suppliers must act with honesty, integrity, and loyalty in consumer relationships. This means avoiding any act that could be considered abusive or misleading.
Principle of Full Prevention and Repair of Damages: The consumer has the right to full compensation (material, moral, direct, and indirect) for damages caused by defects in products or services, including the replacement of defective parts without additional cost and within a reasonable timeframe.
Principle of the National Policy of Consumer Relations: This principle aims to promote the improvement of consumers' quality of life, the harmonization and balance of consumer relations, protecting the health, safety, and economy of consumers, as well as encouraging fair practices in the market.
Principle of Education for Consumption: The CPC encourages the education of consumers and suppliers about rights and duties in consumer relations, promoting awareness and sustainability in the market.
Principle of Effective Prevention and Repression of Infractions: Authorities must act to prevent, curb, and efficiently repress acts contrary to the CPC, ensuring that penalties are applied when necessary to ensure respect for consumer rights.
Understanding these principles is crucial for any entrepreneur, as they guide the creation of customer service, sales, after-sales, and marketing policies that comply with legislation and, more importantly, respect and value consumer rights. This not only avoids legal problems but also contributes to building a positive image of the company in the market, retaining customers, and attracting new business. This is why legal consultancy is so important for your business; all communication with the consumer must be well studied and analyzed so that in the event of a complaint, the company can be sure it has not violated any principle defined by the Consumer Protection Code (CPC).
Defective Product or Poor Service under the Consumer Protection Code (CPC)
In this increasingly connected and informed world, consumers are more aware of their rights, and as suppliers, we need to be equally informed to ensure not only the satisfaction of our customers but also the sustainability and growth of our businesses. After all, understanding Consumer Law is not just about complying with legal obligations, but also a smart business strategy.
So, if you want to stand out in the market, ensuring that your products or services align with consumer expectations and current legislation, you're in the right place. Let's together simplify these concepts and ensure that your venture is always a step ahead.
Defect and Fact in Products or Services: What's the Difference?
A defect occurs when a product or service doesn't work as it should. Imagine you bought a blender that won't turn on, or an internet service that keeps dropping. That's a defect. It's something that prevents the normal use of the product or service.
A fact is more serious. We're talking about problems that, in addition to preventing use, can cause harm to the consumer, like an injury caused by a defective product or a service that puts the consumer's safety at risk.
Consummer Rights: Articles and Guarantees
The Consumer Protection Code (CPC), Law No. 8.078, of September 11, 1990, establishes a series of fundamental rights for consumers. Let's detail some of these rights, linking them to the respective articles of the Law.
Right to Protection of Life, Health, and Safety - Article 6, I - Consumers have the basic right to protection against risks posed by practices in the provision of products and services considered dangerous or harmful.
Right to Consumer Education - Article 6, II - This article ensures the right to education and dissemination about the proper consumption of products and services, ensuring freedom of choice and equality in contracts.
Right to Information - Article 6, III - Guarantees the right to clear and adequate information about different products and services, with correct specification of quantity, characteristics, composition, quality, and price, as well as the potential risks they present.
Right to Protection Against Misleading and Abusive Advertising - Article 6, IV - This right protects consumers against misleading and abusive advertising, coercive or unfair commercial methods, as well as abusive or imposed practices and clauses in the provision of products and services.
Right to Modification of Contractual Clauses - Article 6, V - Consumers can review or modify contractual clauses that establish disproportionate provisions or become excessively burdensome due to supervening facts that make them excessively burdensome.
Right to Compensation for Damages - Article 6, VI - This article ensures the right to effective prevention and compensation for material and moral damages, individual, collective, and diffuse.
Right to Accessibility - Article 6, VIII - Consumers have the right to facilitate the defense of their rights, including the reversal of the burden of proof in their favor in civil proceedings when, at the judge's discretion, the claim is plausible or when they are underprivileged, according to ordinary rules of experiences.
Right of Regret - Article 49 - Consumers can withdraw from the contract within 7 days from its signing or from the act of receiving the product or service, whenever the contracting of the supply of products and services occurs outside of the commercial establishment, especially by telephone or at home.
These articles and rights ensure a solid foundation for consumer protection, ensuring that their needs and safety are prioritized in commercial transactions. Knowledge of these rights is essential for entrepreneurs to effectively respect them and understand their legal obligations. Sometimes you might think that the standard contract template you found on Google is perfect for your business, but it could contain clauses considered excessive by the courts and be invalidated.
Supplier Duties: Articles and Obligations
The Consumer Protection Code (CPC), Law No. 8.078, of September 11, 1990, not only establishes rights for consumers but also imposes a series of duties on suppliers of products and services. Here, we'll explore some of these duties, correlating them to the respective articles of the Law.
Duty to Inform - Article 31 - Suppliers have the duty to offer clear and precise information about the product or service, including its characteristics, quality, quantity, composition, price, guarantees, expiry dates, and origin, among others.
Duty to Protect Against Misleading and Abusive Advertising - Article 37 - It is forbidden for suppliers to engage in misleading or abusive advertising. Advertising must be honest and not mislead the consumer.
Duty to Fulfill Offers - Article 35 - Suppliers are obligated to fulfill all advertised offers. Otherwise, the consumer can demand the forced fulfillment of the offer, accept another equivalent product or service, or terminate the contract with the right to refund any amount possibly paid in advance.
Duty to Provide Adequate Service - Article 20 - When services are not provided according to quality norms that ensure safety, health, durability, and expected performance, the consumer can demand the re-execution of services, refund of the amount paid, or a proportional price reduction.
Duty to Guarantee the Product - Article 26 - Suppliers are obligated to respect the legal and contractual warranty periods of products, allowing the consumer to exchange or repair the defective product within the established timeframe.
Duty to Prevent and Repair Damages - Articles 12 and 14 - Suppliers are responsible for any damages caused by their products or services to consumers, regardless of fault. This includes the obligation to compensate for material and moral damages.
Duty to Facilitate Consumer Defense - Article 6, VIII - Although this article is directly related to consumer rights, it implies the supplier's duty not to create obstacles for consumers wishing to exercise their rights, especially in relation to the reversal of the burden of proof in favor of the consumer.
Duty to Respect the Right of Regret - Article 49 - Suppliers must respect the consumer's right to regret the purchase or contracting of a service made outside the commercial establishment, allowing the return of the product or cancellation of the service within 7 days for a full refund of any amount paid.
Complying with these duties is essential to ensure a fair, balanced consumer relationship in compliance with current legislation. They reflect the responsibility of suppliers to ensure customer satisfaction and the protection of consumer rights.
Situations of Supplier's Exemption from Liability
The Consumer Protection Code (CPC), at its core, seeks to protect consumer rights, ensuring that suppliers of products and services are responsible for any defects or damages that may arise. However, there are specific situations in which the supplier may be exempt from liability. Let's detail these situations and provide examples.
Exclusive Fault of the Consumer or Third Party - Explanation: The supplier will not be held responsible when it is proven that the damage was exclusively the fault of the consumer or a third party.
Example: If a consumer spills liquid on their smartphone, damaging it, or if a third party, not related to the supplier, performs an inadequate installation of a product, causing it to malfunction, the supplier cannot be held responsible for these damages.
Force Majeure or Act of God - Explanation: These are unpredictable and unavoidable situations that prevent the fulfillment of the assumed obligation. In these cases, the supplier is also exempt from liability.
Example: If a delivery company cannot deliver a product on time due to a natural disaster, such as a flood or earthquake, that makes it impossible to access the consumer's region, this situation is considered force majeure.
Non-existent Defect - Explanation: When no defect is found in the product or service, i.e., the product operates as expected and according to the manufacturer's specifications, the supplier is not responsible.
Example: If a consumer complains that their television is defective because it does not access a certain application, but the purchased model does not have this functionality as a feature, the supplier is not responsible for this "defect".
Third-Party Product - Explanation: When the damage is caused exclusively by components or services provided by third parties, and the main product does not contribute to the damage.
Example: If a car is involved in an accident due to the exclusive failure of the tires, which are from a different brand than the vehicle and were chosen and installed by the consumer themselves, the car manufacturer may not be held responsible for the accident.
Adequate Information and Non-observance by the Consumer - Explanation: When the supplier proves that they provided all necessary information about the correct use or installation of the product or service, but the consumer does not follow these instructions.
Example: If an appliance comes with a detailed manual of instructions and warnings about its installation and use, but the consumer ignores these guidelines and uses the product incorrectly, resulting in damage, the supplier may be exempt from liability.
These situations of exemption from liability are essential to ensure justice and equity in consumer relations, recognizing that suppliers cannot always or should not be held responsible for damages or defects. It's important, however, for both consumers and suppliers to be well-informed about their rights and duties to avoid misunderstandings and ensure responsible consumption practices.
Common Misunderstandings
Exchange and Return Policy: Many business owners believe they can freely define their exchange policies without observing the determinations of the CPA. For example, denying the exchange of a defective product, claiming that the responsibility lies with the manufacturer, is a mistake. The law determines that the entire supply chain is jointly responsible.
Misleading Advertising: Some marketing strategies can be interpreted as misleading or abusive advertising without the business owner realizing it. Promising features that the product does not possess or omitting relevant information can lead to severe sanctions.
Tied Selling: Offering a product only on the condition that the consumer purchases another, known as tied selling, is a practice prohibited by the CPA. Business owners may believe they are making a promotion, when in fact they are violating the law.
In summary, the complexity of consumer relations and the constant dynamics of the laws regulating them make legal advice not just advisable but essential for small and medium-sized business owners. Investing in specialized guidance is a protective measure against legal and financial risks and a strategic step towards the sustainable growth and strengthening of the business. Prevention is always the best path, and compliance with the CPC not only avoids legal issues but also promotes a positive image of the company in the market, contributing to customer loyalty and satisfaction.
The Role of Legal Advice
The Consumer Protection Code (CPC) is a powerful instrument for ensuring fair and balanced consumer transactions, but its complexity and breadth demand specialized attention and underline the necessity of legal counsel.
Why Legal Counsel is Crucial?
Conflict Prevention: Legal counsel can foresee issues by guiding businesses on practices that fully respect consumer rights. This minimizes the risk of litigation, which can be costly and damage the company's image.
Constant Updates: Laws and judicial interpretations are always evolving. Specialized professionals keep up with these changes, ensuring that the business practices remain current.
Customization of Strategies: Every business is unique. Legal counsel can provide tailored solutions that meet the specific needs of the business while complying with existing legislation.
Customizing contracts and business policies involves a deep understanding of the business's market, consumer expectations and needs, and the legal nuances governing supplier-consumer relationships. Each business is unique, and its contractual practices and policies should reflect that uniqueness. Some benefits can be:
Conflict Prevention: Customized contracts and policies are clear, specific, and tailored to the company's operations and its consumers' needs, significantly reducing the risk of misunderstandings and legal disputes.
Brand Strengthening: Fair return and transparent contracting policies not only comply with legal obligations but also convey reliability and respect to consumers, strengthening the brand.
Flexibility and Innovation: Customization allows businesses to adapt more quickly to market changes or legislation, incorporating innovations or adjusting to new consumer demands.
Trust Relationship: By demonstrating concern in adapting contracts and policies to the specific needs of consumers, the company builds a solid foundation of trust and loyalty.
Customizing contracts and business policies is an investment that yields significant returns in terms of legal risk prevention, brand strengthening, and building a trust relationship with consumers. Specialized legal consultancy plays a crucial role in this process, ensuring that customization is effective and complies with current legislation. Entrepreneurs who recognize the importance of this customization are a step ahead in building solid, responsible, and successful businesses.
Consequences of Non-Compliance with the Consumer Protection Code (CPC)
Non-compliance with the provisions set by the Consumer Protection Code (CPC) can lead to a range of negative consequences for businesses, from administrative penalties to direct impacts on the company's image and sustainability. Understanding these consequences is crucial for entrepreneurs to grasp the importance of strictly adhering to consumer protection norms.
Administrative Penalties
Non-compliance can result in various administrative sanctions imposed by consumer protection agencies, including:
Fines, which can be significant, especially as the amount is calculated based on the severity of the infraction, the benefit gained, and the supplier's economic condition.
Product seizure.
Closure of the commercial establishment.
Revocation of the establishment or activity license.
Legal Repercussions
Beyond administrative penalties, non-compliance can lead to serious legal consequences, such as:
Class actions filed by entities or the Public Prosecutor's Office on behalf of affected consumers.
Individual actions for moral and material damages, which can result in substantial compensation.
Inclusion of the company's name on lists of bad suppliers, damaging its market reputation.
Impact on Image and Consumer Relationship
The consequences of non-compliance extend beyond administrative and legal spheres. There's a significant impact on the company's image and its relationship with consumers:
Loss of trust: Trust is a company's most valuable asset. CPC violations can quickly destroy trust built over years.
Negative repercussion on social media and in the media: In the digital age, a single negative experience can go viral, affecting the perception of thousands or even millions of potential consumers.
Decrease in customer loyalty: Consumers who feel disrespected or harmed are less likely to remain loyal to the brand and may influence others to do the same.
Conclusion and Practical Suggestions
Non-compliance with the Consumer Protection Code (CPC) brings severe consequences, ranging from administrative and legal penalties to negative impacts on image and customer relations, directly affecting the business's sustainability and success. Adhering to consumer protection norms is not just a legal obligation but a cornerstone for building a solid and respected brand in the market.
To avoid the negative consequences of non-compliance and, more importantly, to build a relationship of trust and satisfaction with consumers, it's crucial for companies to adopt proactive compliance practices. Here are some practical suggestions for implementing legal counsel's guidance in daily business operations:
Regular Trainings: Conducting regular trainings for the entire team focused on consumer rights and supplier duties is essential. These trainings should be constantly updated to reflect legislative changes and ensure the team is informed about the best customer service and conflict resolution practices.
Best Practices Manual: Creating a best practices manual in compliance with the CPC can serve as a quick reference for the team, helping standardize procedures and ensure operations align with consumer protection norms.
Quality Management Systems: Adopting quality management systems focused on customer satisfaction can help identify and correct processes that may not comply with the CPC, promoting a culture of continuous improvement.
Effective Communication Channels: Establishing effective communication channels with consumers that allow not only for quick and efficient problem resolution but also for collecting feedback to improve products and services.
Permanent Legal Consultancy: Maintaining specialized legal counsel in Consumer Law, which can provide ongoing guidance on compliance with the CPC and how to proceed in dispute cases.
By implementing these suggestions, companies not only minimize the risks of penalties and damage to their reputation but also strengthen their market position as responsible brands committed to consumer satisfaction and well-being. Compliance with the CPC should be seen as an investment in the business's long-term sustainability and growth, creating an environment where consumer trust and loyalty are considered valuable assets.
you can find our legal Consultancy Plans here https://www.ennser.adv.br/planos